TABLE OF CONTENTS
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Freedom to operate (FTO) checks whether a product can be marketed without infringing existing patents.
- An FTO analysis relies on identifying the essential technical features of the innovation.
- Searching for and analyzing active patents makes it possible to assess legal risks before going to market.
- If a blocking patent is found, several solutions exist: licensing, technical workarounds, or challenging it.
The freedom to operate — or FTO — consists of determining whether a product can be marketed without infringing patents or intellectual-property rights held by third parties. This guide walks you through the essential steps for navigating this complex landscape, while benefiting from the valuable advice of our Senior Patent Engineer, Catherine Derbois, to secure every phase of your project.
Freedom to operate: definition and challenges
When you develop a new innovation, it is essential to understand how it fits into the existing intellectual-property landscape.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) defines freedom to operate as a legal assessment aimed at determining whether the manufacture, use or sale of a product or process can take place without infringing intellectual-property rights held by third parties, such as patents, in a specific jurisdiction and at a given point in time.
What’s the difference between freedom to operate and prior-art research?
Freedom-to-operate research aims to check that a product or process can be commercially exploited without infringing active patents, whereas prior-art research aims to make sure an invention is new and inventive, so that it can be filed as a patent.
Now that these two clearly different concepts have been established, it’s time to look at the concrete steps for securing your freedom to operate.
Step 1: Precisely define the subject of your innovation
List its essential features
The first step is to identify the precise subject for which you want to check your freedom to operate. This could be a machine, a molecule, a marker, a product, or a manufacturing process.
The next step is to determine this subject’s essential technical features, meaning the elements that make it work and give it its main function.
These features must not only provide technical added value, but must also be new and inventive compared with existing solutions. It is important to take an objective approach in this analysis, taking into account the facts and the technical points that genuinely bring something new.
How do you do it?
To carry out this step, it is recommended that you work closely with your engineers, as well as your marketing and sales teams. They will be able to pin down the product’s technical aspects and identify its differentiating elements in the market.
Where possible, it is recommended that you limit the number of technical features you consider essential. An effective analysis should focus on 3 or 4 key points. This avoids losing your way during the technology-monitoring and patent-search step that follows.
Expert tip: “Don’t spread yourself too thin! Focus on the aspects that genuinely characterize your innovation.”
Step 2: Search for relevant patents
The second step is to carry out prior-art searches, in patents only, focusing on the technical features you have identified. This phase is absolutely necessary for determining whether existing patents claim these features and could therefore block your freedom to operate. These searches should be conducted as broadly as possible on an international level, and in this context, the quality of the database you use will matter.
Define keywords and players
For each technical feature, you need to:
- Define keyword lists that precisely describe the feature’s functionality.
- Identify the sector’s key players who work in the same field of activity. This will help you target relevant patents and make sure none are missing from this initial search.
Search patent databases
Searches must be conducted over a 20-year period, since that is the maximum term of validity of a patent. You will use these keywords and players to search the available patent databases. Although there are freely accessible databases, this task can be complex and laborious.
Expert tip: “To simplify and centralize your searches, tools like IPMetrix are essential. They let you aggregate data from different databases, carry out targeted searches, and generate precise statistics on the results.”
Step 3: Analyze your results
Analyzing the patent claims for each of the 3 features
Once the searches have been carried out, you will get a list of results for each technical feature. Each feature should be the subject of its own specific query. However, the work doesn’t stop there. You then need to examine the patent claims.
Claims are the part of a patent that carries legal weight, and they determine the scope of protection. You need to check whether the technical feature you are analyzing is claimed and whether it is associated with the functionality you are developing.
The goal? To identify whether a competing patent claims a technical feature identical or very close to the one you want to use for the same functionality. If so, your search is already a success, because you have just identified a potential threat.
Checking the legal status of patents
Once the relevant documents have been identified, you need to examine their legal status. You need to check:
- The countries in which the patent is filed.
- Whether the patent is still valid in those countries (still in force or not): if the patent has fallen into the public domain, then the technology it describes is free to use.
Possible scenarios
- If the patent has lapsed (is no longer valid), you are free to use the technology in that country.
- If the patent is valid in some countries but not others, you need to analyze this based on your manufacturing locations (where your plants are) and/or your target markets. For example, if the patent is still in force in a country where you do not plan to sell or manufacture, you are free to operate in the other countries.
Summary table
At this stage, you get a table that lets you sort patents into three categories:
-
- Irrelevant patents (they do not describe the targeted technical features).
- Relevant patents that are no longer in force in the target countries.
- Patents that are relevant and in force in your countries of interest, and need further analysis.
Expert tip: “By processing your results this way, you will get a clear list of problematic patents — the ones that could stand in the way of your freedom to operate.”
Step 4: Check the protection of the object as a whole
Overall analysis
Once you have analyzed the essential technical features individually, it’s time to move on to analyzing the complete object. This means checking whether the whole device, incorporating all of these features, has already been protected by a patent. The focus is no longer on a single feature, but on the combination of these features within an overall device.
The goal of this step is to search for patents that describe a similar device to the one you plan to market. You need to examine how the identified patents structure and protect the object as a whole, to check whether they use one or more of the essential features you have defined.
-
- Search for patents covering the whole object: It is essential to identify patents that describe the object in its entirety, not just isolated elements.
- Analyze the documents retained: If a patent describes the whole device and uses one or more of your essential technical features, that document should be kept for further analysis.
- Eliminate irrelevant patents: If a patent does not cover the essential features as a whole, it can be removed from the analysis process.
Expert tip: “Be careful, your monitoring doesn’t stop there! Since these searches and analyses take place over a long period, new patent applications may have been filed but not yet published at the time of your search.”
Step 5: What to do if you find a blocking patent?
If a blocking patent is identified, several options are possible:
- Negotiating a license: You can negotiate with the patent holder to obtain a license to use the technology. This lets you use the technology legally in exchange for a royalty.
- Technical workaround: It is possible to adapt your technology to work around the troublesome patent’s claims and thereby avoid any infringement.
- Challenging validity: If you believe the patent is not valid, you can gather evidence (prior art, etc.) to challenge its validity before the relevant authorities.
Expert tip: “Negotiating a license is often more cost-effective than launching costly legal proceedings. Depending on how important the patent is, you can base the royalty on the real impact of the protected technology.”
The main pitfalls to avoid
- Underestimating claims: Focus on granted patents — it’s the claims that define legal protection.
- Underestimating commercial risks: Don’t underestimate the financial impact a blocking patent can have on your company.
- Ignoring the timing of patents: Patents evolve. Redo your analysis 3 to 6 months before going to market, to make sure no new patent has been filed.
- Don’t hesitate to consult an expert: A Patent Engineer or an IP Counsel will help you carry out the right searches and analyses, and then avoid costly disputes.
Securing freedom to operate for your innovation is a complex process that requires centralizing and analyzing a large volume of information. A tool like the TKM platform simplifies this task by letting you centralize all the data on your technical features and patents, carry out active monitoring, track developments among your competitors and the state of the art, and manage risks more effectively.
Our solutions can also support you on various aspects of your innovation projects.
What’s more, support from TKM’s experts helps you avoid the main pitfalls and secure your project. Need support to innovate? Contact our teams!